Case Study: Inline Process for Quality Assurance of Weld Seams #Manufacturing #3dStahl

Miscellaneous welding tasks in steel constructions currently have a low degree of automation, resulting in a high amount of manual work and employee-dependent quality levels.

As part of the 3dStahl collaborative project, a 6-axis robot, equipped with a welding machine, was attached upside down to a wall-to-wall wire rope hoist kinematics system in order to automate joining processes involving small quantities or even individual parts such as large-scale objects (lock gates, bridges). Fast 3D sensor technology provides three-dimensional data for defining the welding area. This data is used to position and track the welding robot. The continuous process quality assurance is achieved in parallel by means of an infrared camera and a multi-spectral camera system.

The infrared camera detects the emissivity change and intensity distribution of the infrared radiation emitted by the resulting weld. The intensity is the specific radiation in W/m², meaning which power is radiated from the measurement object per area. The measurement of the absolute weld temperature is only possible to a limited extent due to the reflective properties of the metal material and variable emissivity associated with the weld molten mass. Nevertheless, in-line process control is possible and influencing welding parameters can be derived by examining relative intensity changes within the measurement series using the measurement instrument.

Test Object

For the analysis, two steel sheets are placed in a T-joint, so that one part hits the other vertically with the front. The resulting fillet weld between these sheets is examined during the process.

Meas­ure­ment System

An infrared camera VarioCAM® HD head 800 from InfraTec with a detector format of (1,024 × 768) IR pixels and a frame rate of 30 Hz in full-frame is used for the inline process control. With a working distance of 300 mm and a lens with a focal length of 30 mm, the detectable object size is (178 × 133) mm2.

Manu­fac­turing and Meas­ure­ment Methods

The two sheets are welded together by means of metal-active gas welding (MAG). The flow rate of the shielding gas required for this purpose is varied in the individual measurements in order to examine its influence on the quality of the weld. The welding speed of the process is 25 cm/min.

During the ongoing process, the resulting weld is monitored by the VarioCAM® HD head 800 continuously and the change in emissivity and intensity distribution of the weld are analysed in real time. In addition to the infrared data, the welding parameters such as welding current and voltage are recorded, which allow to draw additional conclusions concerning the weld quality.

The change in emissivity can be attributed to the change in the physical state as well as the corrosion of the weld in the atmosphere. The transition between the different emissivities describes a characteristic course, which correlates directly with the quality of the resulting welds.

Changes in shape and asymmetries of the weld can be detected by means of the intensity distribution and intensity profile along the weld. A strong decrease in the profile signifies a strong structural change in the contour of the weld.


Changes in emissivities

The weld shown in Fig. 1 has been produced with an shielding gas flow rate of 12 l/min. This value was defined as the setpoint under visual inspection criteria. At some distance from the welding event – white dot with a red border – a parabolic shape in the direction of the welding process forms at the transition of the emissivities – the area within the red frame. In the case of a weld generated with a gas flow rate of 4.5 l/min (Fig. 2), the transition of the emissivity change shows a straight shape here.

This characteristic shape was reproducible in further tests. In addition, the character of the parabolic curve is directly dependent on the gas flow rate used.

Intensity distribution

Fig. 3 shows the intensity distributions (a and b) and the corresponding intensity profiles (c and d) along a weld. The images and diagrams represent the moment immediately after completion of a weld area. A misalignment of the welding torch results in an asymmetrical weld. The result of this welding fault becomes clear in the intensity distribution, but above all in the associated intensity profile. This can be seen in Fig. 3 d) by a strong decline in intensity at the beginning of the change in shape. By comparison, the profile of the defect-free weld follows an almost linearly rising trend.

Fig. 3 Intensity distribution (a, b), profile (c, d) and colour image of a (e) defect-free and (f) defective weld. The different scales in the image sections (c) and (d) should be noted:


Passive thermography is particularly suitable for the qualitative assessment of processes with high intrinsic heat. Due to the different emissivities of solid and molten metal, quantification of the weld temperatures is only possible to a limited extent. For this reason, the relative changes of the radiation are of greater interest in these tests.

The results show that in particular the change in the emissivities as well as the examination of the intensity profile, allow to obtain reliable information regarding the quality of the weld.

Further inform­a­tion about infrared camera Vari­oCAM® HD head 800

Manufacturing Update